Basic errors cost Reds

James Hanson of the Reds charges into the defence during the Super Rugby Qualifying Final between the Reds and the Sharks at Suncorp Stadium on July 21, 2012 in Brisbane, Australia.
James Hanson of the Reds charges into the defence during the Super Rugby Qualifying Final between the Reds and the Sharks at Suncorp Stadium on July 21, 2012 in Brisbane, Australia. Bradley Kanaris - Getty Images

WOW, what a game!

The Reds versus Sharks final was a cracker. As far as Reds' supporters and this columnist go, not the result we were after. But nonetheless it was a great game of rugby, and for that we should all rejoice.

Another aspect to rejoice about was the fact the best team won.

The Sharks brought their smothering defence, they were clinical in attack, and the dreaded penalty/penalty goal nexus played no part. It was true rugby entertainment.

First, I must address the elephant in the room. A lot (in the Aussie press anyway) has been made about the performance of the referee group (Kaplan and his touchies). As far as I'm concerned, while it won't be one they'll cherish as their best performance, they were not responsible for the Reds' downfall.

The Reds were their own worst enemies. Far too many basic mistakes and questionable defence was the key to their loss.

Kaplan's sin-binning of a Sharks player for repeated team offences on full time probably came a bit too late. But once again, if the home side had held onto the ball and made the critical tackles, it would have won the game.

In addition, having been at the game and in a favourable position to view the game aerially, Kaplan and the touchies missed, conservatively, about fifteen forward passes, favouring both teams equally. The game resembled full-contact netball on many occasions.

A couple of other aspects of the game caught my attention and they were both related to the unfortunate injury to Ben Lucas (You have to feel for him, he's had really bad luck with injuries of late) and both have positive long-term impact for the Reds.

As Lucas was leaving the field, to most people's surprise, the versatile Nick Frisby came on as his replacement with Will Genia moving to five-eighth. I thought both had productive games.

You could argue the Reds failed to reach any great highs in continuity or effectiveness with their attack, but it was not the result of these two players. The quality of the Sharks defence was the major impacting factor on the Reds attack.

 

Aussie conference

So, it's game over for Aussie teams in Super Rugby for 2012.

Overall, probably a true reflection of the standing of the Aussie teams in this year's competition. Super Rugby has evolved, providing fundamental challenges to the Australian franchises.

First to the disappointing.

The Force is a worry, and you wonder if they will ever live up to their marketer's eponymous name in Super Rugby.

And the Tahs were/are, well, the Tahs. By far the Aussie conference's inveterate under achievers. Though, you think they are close to rock-bottom and the only way up is, well.

Now to the positive. The Rebels provided some positives and hope for the future. Their wins against the Blues in round seven and their crushing of the Crusaders in round twelve are indicative of such promise. But they need to be more consistent, especially against the mid-table teams.

The Brumbies were solid throughout the year, and will be disappointed in their meek departure prior to the finals. But there's plenty to be positive about around the nation's capital.

And as for the Reds, injuries hamstrung the early part of their season and although they finished strong toward the end of the year, found defending a title much more challenging than fighting to win one.

With Ewan McKenzie moving to a director of coaching-type role and Richard Graham to head coach, it'll be interesting to see how this works in 2013.

Overall, depth is still Australian rugby's weak point. But, keep the faith. Year on year, player by player, team by team Super Rugby is the instrument through which Australian rugby will grow stronger.

Until next Super Season, hooroo!

Topics:  natal coastal sharks, queensland reds, super 15 rugby




Local Real Estate

finda logo
Featured Real Estate
Ultra Rare in Junction... Offers Over...
House 3 1 1
The Ultimate Beach... AUCTION
House 5 2 2
Job Promotion... Offers Over...
House 4 1 3
Another $10,000 Off ... $375,000
House 4 2 2

Featured Jobs

finda logo

Clarence Valley jobs listed daily

Featured Jobs
We are seeking an... Coffs Harbour Full Time
FULL TIME WEB... Fortitude Valley Full Time 75,000 - 100,000
GENERAL MANAGER ... Gladstone Full Time $120 - $150
BRIDGESTONE SELECT ... Grafton Full Time


Local Partners

LATEST DEALS AND OFFERS

Free Seed Packets

with token from today's paper
Learn More

Cars For Sale

Find cars for sale online now.
Learn More

Property Listings

Post an ad from $30
Learn More

Local Profile

Stay Connected

Get the news as it happens, in your inbox

You can change the newsletters you are subscribed to when you edit your profile

Edit Profile


Special Offers

Latest deals and offers

View today's ePaper!

Read the digital edition
Learn More

Horoscopes

Virgo

This could be a day where you decide to spend big on clothing, jewellery and other fashion items that could make you feel more attractive. It...

read more

Marketplace

Special Offers & Promotions

Compare & Save