News

Woman beaten and stabbed, then burnt

AFTERMATH: Police investigating the burnt shell of the house at 10 Margaret Cr, South Grafton, where Michelle Roberts' body was found.
AFTERMATH: Police investigating the burnt shell of the house at 10 Margaret Cr, South Grafton, where Michelle Roberts' body was found.

A WOMAN murdered in South Grafton in May 2012 had been beaten and stabbed 24 times before her body was burnt in a house fire, a Supreme Court trial in Grafton heard yesterday.

Andrew Sumpton, 49, of South Grafton is on trial for the murder of Michelle Roberts in South Grafton on May 18, 2012.

He also faces two charges of causing malicious damage by fire.

The trial, before a jury of seven men and five women, opened yesterday.

After opening addresses from the Crown and defence barrister Mr Dennis, the court heard evidence from the forensic pathologist who performed the autopsy on Ms Roberts.

Newcastle forensic pathologist Dr Brian Beer told the court that from the injuries and the state of the body he was able to come up with the most likely sequence of injuries.

He said blunt force trauma to the face of the victim indicated she had been most likely knocked unconscious and then stabbed.

He came to this conclusion because of the absence of defensive injuries on the hands, palms and arms of the victim.

Dr Beer said the woman had been stabbed 18 times in the chest and abdomen and six times in the upper thighs and genital area.

Four of the stab wounds pierced her heart, any of which would have been fatal.

He said from the waist up the front of Ms Roberts's had been burnt beyond recognition. From the burn marks he concluded Ms Roberts had been lying on her back when the fire started.

Blood analysis revealed a blood alcohol reading of .231 plus the presence of marijuana and Valium in her system.

The Crown Prosecutor's opening address outlined the actions of Sumpton and Ms Roberts in the hours leading up to her death.

He told how she had met Sumpton for the first time the day before during a drinking session with another man.

He said she and Sumpton had taken the third man back to his house in Margaret Cres, South Grafton, where he obtained a bottle of home-brew whisky, which they intended to drink.

Before leaving Sumpton indicated he thought he would have sex

with Ms Roberts.

He went on to tell how witnesses described seeing Ms Roberts and Sumpton at various times leading up to the fire alarm at around 2am.

The prosecution also said its case would rely on testimony of two witnesses who claim Sumpton confessed to them about the murder.

These include a prison officer who said Sumpton told him he had rolled her body in a blanket and then set fire to it, to destroy evidence.

"I had to. She was f****d. I had to get rid of the evidence," the officer reported Sumpton told him.

The other evidence of a confession came from a prisoner at Grafton Jail.

The Crown also said there was other forensic evidence which made a compelling case against Sumpton.

Mr Dennis said there was no doubt Ms Roberts was murdered and a fire deliberately lit to cover the tracks of the murderer.

He said his client admits he was with the victim before the murder, but was not involved in her murder or the subsequent fire.

He said there would be serious questions asked of the two confession witnesses, one of whom is a prisoner who gained a reduction in his sentence to testify.

Mr Dennis said the times people said certain things happened would show his client could not have been there at the time of the murder and the fire.

He said there would also be questions asked of Ms Roberts's boyfriend, who told police he had not seen Ms Roberts since the Tuesday before her death.

The trial continues today.

Topics:  editors picks murder south grafton supreme court



Look My Way into ArtExpress

Ruby Sullivan of McAuley Catholic College has had her major HSC artwork accepted into the annual ArtExpress exhibition.

McAuley student's HSC artwork selected for exhibition

'That's not a brown!': Rare snake found lurking

Snakes have an inoffensive nature and are reluctance to bite

Spotify Summer tour kicks back in the Clarence Valley

David Harrison, Thom Moore and Beatrice McBride pose in the back of their truck for #spotifysummer

Head down to Minnie Water and Wooli to meet the crew from Spotify.

Local Partners

Dakota's world beating spectacular performance

Dancer helps break world record at School Spectacular performance


Kernaghan's a 'boy from the bush' with a timeless quality

Country music singer Lee Kernaghan.

Lee Kernaghan is celebrating the 25th year of his breakthrough song.

Ready to rumble: Boxing makes long-awaited return to Grafton

DETERMINED: Grafton Amateur Boxing Club members Zac Cotten (Cruiserweight), James Morrison (Jnr Featherweight), Eddie Debono (Super Heavyweight), Rhys Walters (Light Heavyweight), Joseph Pigg (Jnr Welterweight), Jamie Mansfield (Cruiserweight) are prearing for upcoming fight night in Grafton.

Five North Coast title belts up for grabs

Cyclist's 24 hours of pain for mental health

International endurance mountain-bike rider Morgan Pilley is used to pushing through the elements, but this weekend he'll push on to raise money for local mental health services in a charity ride at Junction Hill.

Ride For Youth to raise money for local youth mental health services

Justin Timberlake stuns students with secret class

Justin Timberlake stunned high school students in Sydney

Carrie Fisher says Ford will be bugged by affair confession

Carrie Fisher is sure Harrison Ford is annoyed at her

Dakota Fanning rekindles romance with childhood sweetheart

Dakota Fanning rekindles romance with ex

Jennifer Lawrence apologises to the people of Hawaii

Jennifer Lawrence sorry for 'offensive' story

Cruz Beckham's single a 'one-off'

He is not planning to launch a full-time music career yet.

Louis Tomlinson's mother dies aged 42

Louis Tomlinson's mother has died.

Five South Grafton houses that won't break the bank

Check out these South Grafton houses for sale

'Crucial' farm land eyed by defence department

Lawson Geddes moving the Brangus cattle to higher ground - which is the land the Defence Department is interested taking for the Shoalwater Bay expansion.

"You can't have one without the other.”

Former Shark Show for sale for $1.3 million

Vic Hislop at the old Shark Show.

TALK about a jaws-dropping real estate opportunity.

There's a whole lot of luxury in this home

The Endeavour Foundation's latest prize home in Mountain Creek.

WHEN it comes to desirable homes, it's hard to go past a prize home.

Give a little more this Christmas

TIME TO GIVE: Lee Johns, Courtney Smith and Daniel Kelly of Ray White Yamba promote their Little Ray Of Giving Christmas gift appeal.

Call out for presents, big or small

Ready to SELL your property?

Post Your Ad Here!