Little joy for Happy Paws

Happy Paws Haven operator Sally Rogers outside Grafton courthouse on Monday.
Happy Paws Haven operator Sally Rogers outside Grafton courthouse on Monday. Adam Hourigan

ANY hope of finding a solution yesterday to the ongoing dispute between Happy Paws operator Sally Rogers and her Eatonsville neighbours vanished shortly after the lunch break when it became clear there would be no time left in the Land and Environment Court proceedings to hear from acoustic experts.

In a day punctuated by bitter remarks between the legal counsels for Ms Rogers and Clarence Valley Council, Justice Rachel Pepper called for better co-operation between the parties.

The case is centred on the conditions of a CVC-issued noise prevention notice.

While Ms Rogers has completed a number of the actions set down in the notice, including the installation of sound-reducing tiles inside the dog enclosures, she is objecting to the conversion of the centre into boarding kennels with dogs housed singularly or in compatible pairs.

Neighbour Jane Dwyer told the court in her written affidavit that the dogs at Happy Paws barked almost hourly, but Ms Rogers' lawyer Chris Adamson questioned the claim and asked if she was woken up every hour at night.

"Not once did I say that I was woken up hourly by the dogs," Ms Dwyer said.

Mr Adamson put it to Ms Dwyer that the dogs did not bark for long periods at a time, but instead only a few minutes before someone from Happy Paws calmed the dogs.

"This is totally incorrect," Ms Dwyer responded.

Asked if she would allow contractors onto her land so a fence could be built to help reduce noise, Mrs Dwyer said she would not because the situation had deteriorated drastically in recent times.

"I feel I have been made to feel uncomfortable in my own home," she said.

Troy Campbell said his home was about 275 metres from the Happy Paws boundary and that he owned six dogs, including one larger dog named Tiny which helped protect a flock of sheep on the property from wild dogs.

He said he had reduced the use of a paddock that shared a boundary with Happy Paws because his presence there tended to set off the dogs inside the shelter.

"I am conscious of other neighbours who hear the dogs more than me; it's not pleasant to be up there," he said.

After raising concerns that a horse may put holes in the galvanised fence proposed by Ms Rogers, Mr Campbell said he would consider agreeing to such a fence if it was behind the current barbed wire and post fence on the boundary.

Mr Campbell said ideally he would like to see Happy Paws gone from its current location because there were too many dogs on too small an area and the dogs were virtually on top of each other.

"The yelping I hear sometimes sounds cruel," he said.

Justice Pepper ordered a mediation meeting for all parties before October 5 with a directions hearing on October 12.

She ordered that Ms Rogers hold no more dogs than the current number of 32, plus an unlimited number of puppies (under six months of age), until the matter was determined.

Topics:  animals clarence valley council grafton happy paws land and environment court noise

WATCH: Junior Queen gets silver screen royal treatment

2008 Junior Jacaranda Queen candidates Elora Vest, Rachael Houlahan and Melista King are just a few of the girls who came together to share their stories and be a part of  the new documentary Jaca Girls.

A right royal look at the Junior Jacaranda Queen competition

YOU DECIDE: Should this be our Cover Image this week?

This picture of a shoe from James Spartacus had the most likes for The Daily Examiner's Cover Image photo this week.

Picture of shoe receives most likes for Cover Image

OPINION: Bees kill more than sharks

Bees are up there for killing machines, says editor David Kirkpatrick

Should we have nets for bees?

Local Partners

WATCH: Junior Queen gets silver screen royal treatment

NEW documentary explores the festival's 20-year-old quest as former candidates share their stories and experiences.

Tea party with the 'Queen'

TRADITION: 1955 Jacaranda Queen Stella Wilson sits with reigning 2015 Jacaranda Queen Charlotte White at last year's Jacaranda Afternoon Tea.

Meet the royal patyu in style

Making steps for 'Blacky' in Walk 4 Brain Cancer

Grafton locals are doing a Walk 4 Brain Cancer in Sydney for Robert Black.

Team Blacky aims to better $5000 to battle brain cancer.

Sound of Music star to compere An Afternoon at the Proms

This photo provided by Twentieth Century Fox Home Entertainment shows, from left, Chairmian Carr, as Liesl, Nicholas Hammond, as Friedrich, Heather Menzies, as Louisa, Duane Chase, as Kurt, Angela Cartwright, as Brigitta, Debbie Turner, as Marta, Kym Karath, as Gretl, and Christopher Plummer, as Captain Von Trapp, in a scene from the film, \"The Sound of Music.\" The 1965 Oscar-winning film adaptation of the Rodgers & Hammerstein musical \"The Sound of Music\" is celebrating its 50th birthday in 2015. To honor the milestone, 20th Century Fox is releasing a five-disc Blu-ray/DVD/Digital HD collector's edition, the soundtrack is being re-released, the film will be screened at the TCM Classic Film Festival in Hollywood later this month and to over 500 movie theaters in April. (AP Photo/Twentieth Century Fox Home Entertainment)

Saraton's rich history of stage and screen honoured in musical tribu

Bindi Irwin named in MAXIM HOT 100 list

Wildlife Warrior named among Australia's most beautiful women

Britney Spears suffers wardrobe malfunction

Britney Spears suffered a wardrobe malfunction during performance

'You Spin Me Round' hitmaker dies aged 57

Pete Burns

Pete Burns has died aged 57

REVIEW: Season 7 premiere of The Walking Dead disgusted me

I'm disgusted by The Walking Dead premiere.

SPOILERS: The Walking Dead premiere disgusted me.

Flick teases intense and entertaining Survivor grand final

Felicity 'Flick' Eggington in a scene from the TV series Australian Survivor.

GOLD Coaster's elimination leaves Lee, El and Kristie in final three

Priscilla concerned people will forget about Elvis

Priscilla Presley source Bang

She says she feels responsible to keep his legacy going

Look at me! Kath and Kim home up for sale

Kath and Kim from the iconic Aussie TV series.

'Crack open the Baileys and grab a box of BBQ Shapes'

Hinterland horse stud passed in for $8.25 million

UNREAL: This Maleny estate is incredible.

12-bedroom hinterland horse stud still available

Hit songwriter's Noosa mansion on market

SPECIAL PLACE: The Cintamani estate is going to tender, marketed by Tom Offermann Real Estate.

Is this Queensland's best property?

Kiwi siblings snap up Dotcom mansion for $32.5m

The new toy company owners of the Coatesville mansion want replace any controversy with positivity and fun. Photo / Barfoot and Thompson

The trio paid $32.5 million for the property in June

New $200 million development will create 580 jobs

Cassie And Josh with baby Alfie and daughter Andee. They have bought at new Lennox Head development Epiq.

Majority of new positions will be given to Northern Rivers locals

Cherrabah's mega resort plans axed

PLANS for a massive development at Cherrabah have been scrapped.