Do Queensland's anti-bikie laws go too far? Tony Fitzgerald thinks so.
Do Queensland's anti-bikie laws go too far? Tony Fitzgerald thinks so. Alistair Brightman

Former judge blasts bikie and sexual offender laws

THE former judge who led the fight against corruption in Queensland has warned politicians not to rush into 'foolhardy' new laws without proper research.

In an opinion piece published today, Tony Fitzgerald, AC, QC, said judges too were concerned about the safety of families - and outraged by the actions of criminals.

"Pedophilia is abominable. Violence and bullying are abhorrent. Violence and intimidation in company are cowardly. Profiting from the misery caused by illegal drugs is despicable,'' he wrote.

But he said it was "foolhardy for politicians who lack material expertise to make major changes to the criminal law without first obtaining and acting on advice from criminologists, penologists, prosecutors and other experts.

He warned tougher new laws could actually result in worse outcomes for victims.

READ: Clive Palmer says Newman should apologise to judges

"Draconian penalties might increase the possibility of pedophiles killing children whom they've molested or violent criminals or their associates killing witnesses,'' Mr Fitzgerald said.

"History teaches us that claims that repressive laws will reduce serious crime are usually hollow and that laws which erode individual freedom and expand a state's power over its citizens are fraught with peril.''

Mr Fitzgerald also warned about politicians targeting those opposing the laws. Last week, Premier Campbell Newman called critics of the sex offender laws "apologists" for pedophiles.

"It is extremely arrogant and socially destructive for politicians to slander citizens who disagree with their "political solution" or to denigrate the judicial branch of government and its generally conservative judges who must make sometimes unpopular decisions in accordance with the law and available evidence and their oath of office,'' Mr Fitzgerald said.


WHAT DO YOU THINK? Are Queensland's new laws going too far or have judges been too soft for too long? Leave your comments below and vote in our poll

 

Have Queensland's laws gone too far?

This poll ended on 09 November 2013.

Current Results

Yes. They are not necessary and erode basic human rights

40%

No. Our judges and magistrates are too soft on crime

22%

Yes. Politicians should not interfere with judiciary

25%

No. If the judges don't get it right, new laws should

11%

This is not a scientific poll. The results reflect only the opinions of those who chose to participate.



Tree removal still putting scars onto council

premium_icon Tree removal still putting scars onto council

Council still counting the cost of removing scar tree.

Bobcats ready to fight for their season

premium_icon Bobcats ready to fight for their season

Do-or-die time for Maclean as they look to reach top four

Highway bypass expert brings view on Jacaranda City's future

Highway bypass expert brings view on Jacaranda City's future

Expert on bypasses to help Grafton plan for better future.

Local Partners