News

Fuelled up for failure

Liberty service station on Gwydir Hwy is believed to be the last dealer-owned, dealer-operated petrol station in Grafton. Paul Kelly (pictured) is manager and son of owner Robert Cook.
Liberty service station on Gwydir Hwy is believed to be the last dealer-owned, dealer-operated petrol station in Grafton. Paul Kelly (pictured) is manager and son of owner Robert Cook. JoJo Newby

DODOS are not extinct yet but trading practices by major retailers have left only one in Grafton.

Robert Cook and his Liberty service station on the Gwydir Hwy is the last of Grafton's dealer-owned, dealer-operated (DODO) petrol stations and he blames Coles and Woolworths.

"Coles and Woolworths now have in excess of 50% of the volume of fuel sold in Australia," Mr Cook said.

"When you are dealing with oil companies, good credit is where you get load-to-load credit, meaning you have got 3-4 days credit to pay accounts, not 30-90 days like many businesses," he said.

"If Coles and Woolworths (owned petrol stations) shove prices down for just three or four weeks, that can be just enough to finish off somebody."

Mr Cook said the major retailers' deep pockets provided by their supermarket business gives them the ability to sustain losses on fuel margins for extended periods and force out competitors.

"Once you dominate the pricing situation and the supply situation you also become politically powerful," he said.

Chief executive of the combined Motor Traders and Service Station associations James McCall echoed Mr Cook's concerns.

"The Service Station Association had 600 members three years ago and half of those have dropped out of business," Mr McCall said.

"We believe Coles and Woolworths are artificially reducing prices of petrol in order to force out businesses."

Mr McCall described the cross-subsidisation of shopper-docket supermarket sales into the petrol retail sector as "scandalous" and "immoral," while other practices are misleading.

"We believe their pricing boards confuse the public by showing at the top of their board the price after a discount is applied," he said.

NSW Fair Trading Minister Anthony Roberts is understood to be reviewing allegations of misleading signage.

"We are calling on the Federal Government to grow a backbone on cross-subsidies or they will have no independent service stations and a loss of competition," he said.

"When that happens it is consumers who will be paying."

Cross subsidies are not the only retail practice Robert Cook condemned.

A new convert to the Liberty chain, his Gwydir Hwy service station was previously a Shell garage, the oil company affiliated with Coles.

"We used to take Shell Cards. I was told that given to a complaint from Coles that I was in close proximity to their Bent St site that my Shell Card facility would be removed," he said.

"A few months later someone turned up and took away the Shell Card facility and verbally told me that was the reason."

 

Woolworths responds

Both Woolworths and Coles were asked to respond to these claims and at the time of going to print, only Woolworths had supplied the below statements:

  • We make no apologies for bringing our customers good prices at the pump
  • Competition in the retail petrol market remains strong with many players, and independents make up 40% of the sector
  • Fuel retailing is a low- margin, high-cost business with the majority of the retail price taken up by the wholesale costs and taxes
  • The ACCC, at Senate estimates on February 15, stated their rigorous and detailed analysis had shown there was no relationship between discount docket promotions and the margin between retail and wholesale prices.

Topics:  coles fuel nsw fair trading petrol station woolworths



Work starts on highway overpass

The Pacific Highway upgrade continues

Motorists to be diverted to service Road

Summit the first step for bush footy

One of the round table discussions held by one of the groups led by scribe Col Hennessy during the NSW Grassroots Rugby League Summit staged at the Yamba Sports Complex on Saturday, 18th February, 2017.

Orange Sky Laundry inspiring at grassroots footy summit.

Rebels 'dumbfounded' over Coffs Coast 9s final snub

South Grafton Rebels first grade side at the Coffs Coast 9s.

Coach Ron Gordon admitted club felt like it had been "robbed”.

Local Partners

Hi-tech welcome for bishop

Bishops ordination to be a colourful and reverent event, and if you can't get to the church, youc an watch it on the web


Share a cuppa coffee with a cop

Coffee and conversation go hand in hand in the Clarence whether you like it or not.

Chance to come along and meet your local police officers

Deputy premier on his way to the Clarence Valley

NSW Deputy Premier John Barilaro during question time at NSW Parliament in Sydney, Tuesday, Feb. 14, 2017.  Berejiklian was elected Premier by her party room after Mike Baird announced his shock resignation.(AAP Image/Dean Lewins) NO ARCHIVING

John Barilaro's first visit at NSW deputy

OUR SAY: Perfect opportunity for people with passion

The Mouldy Lovers get the crowd dancing at the Surfing the Coldstream Festival.  Photo Clair Morton / Daily Examiner

Events large or small require helping hands of volunteers

Nadia visits Coast to escape Married At First Sight drama

MARRIED At First Sight contestant Nadia Stamp escaped to the Coast for a girl's weekend to take stock ahead of week of drama.

‘I didn’t stuff it up like you have’: Plibersek on Q&A

“I didn’t stuff it up the way you have stuffed it up, George”: Tanya Plibersek.

Plibersek lashed out at Brandis to plenty of applause

MKR cheating scandal: Alyse and Matt hit back

Matt Jenner shows his MKR rivals the curry paste he and Alyse used.

Alyse and Matt Jenner have hit back at claims they cheated on MKR

MKR rocked by satay sauce cheating scandal

Alyse and Matt slammed for satay sauce fiasco.

'Nasty' Married At First Sight groom ripped apart on TV

Anthony gets torn down during the Married At First Sight commitment ceremony.

MAFS groom Anthony faces the music after fiery dinner party.

MOVIE REVIEW: Matt Damon's The Great Wall gets lost

Matt Damon fails in a scene from the movie The Great Wall.

Did The Great Wall get lost in translation?

Paul Murray listens to regions

Paul Murray is taking his Sky News show on the road to shine a spotlight on regional Australia.

Radio broadcaster wants viewers to 'turn up and fire up'

Popular island resort sells to loaded international investor

OUR PICK: Chris Foey's colourful shot of one of Gladstone's great tourism hot spots, Heron Island.

International investor snaps up piece of Gladstone paradise.

Potential home buyers punished for doing the 'right thing'

Should I go to university or buy a house?

Living with river view

LABOUR OF LOVE: Peter and Narelle Cauldwell are selling Bemuda Estate in Great Marlow (pictured below).

A rare opportunity to own a luxury estate

Clarence River island paradise selling for $5M

Former Ballina councillor Margaret Howes is selling her island getaway.

GALLERY: Tropical getaway with beaches and airstrip put on market.

Ready to SELL your property?

Post Your Ad Here!