MELBOURNE, AUSTRALIA – JUNE 11: Jack Higgins of the Tigers reacts during the 2020 AFL Round 02 match between the Collingwood Magpies and the Richmond Tigers at the Melbourne Cricket Ground on June 11, 2020 in Melbourne, Australia. (Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)
MELBOURNE, AUSTRALIA – JUNE 11: Jack Higgins of the Tigers reacts during the 2020 AFL Round 02 match between the Collingwood Magpies and the Richmond Tigers at the Melbourne Cricket Ground on June 11, 2020 in Melbourne, Australia. (Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

New vision shows why Higgins was paid controversial mark

The AFL has officially approved Jack Higgins' contentious goal-line mark but has admitted Fremantle's Matt Taberner should have been paid a critical mark late in the loss to Brisbane.

The league's football department said it was comfortable with both Higgins' mark and the decision to award a behind when North Melbourne's Jamie McMillan rushed a Toby Greene kick on the goal line.

Higgins' mark on the goal line on Thursday night was heavily criticised by the Channel 7 commentary team, with the mark freeze-framed after he controlled the ball on the line.

New vision used by the AFL's team in its bunker confirms the mark, as it marries up two different TV angles showing Richmond's Higgins controlled the ball on the line.

Kayo is your ticket to the 2020 Toyota AFL Premiership Season. Watch every match of every round Live & On-Demand. New to Kayo? Get your 14-day free trial & start streaming instantly >

 

Jack Higgins’ mark from all angles. Picture: Supplied
Jack Higgins’ mark from all angles. Picture: Supplied

 

Jack Higgins’ mark from all angles. Picture: Supplied
Jack Higgins’ mark from all angles. Picture: Supplied

All of the ball needs to be over the goal line and while the TV camera was not perfectly placed the league has ticked off that mark, which saw Higgins kick the last goal of the game late in the third term.

North Melbourne's McMillan rushed a ball kicked by GWS forward Toby Greene just as it hit the goal line, with the goal umpire calling it a behind in his initial decision.

The third umpire said he did not have definitive evidence to overturn the decision despite the Greene kick looking desperately close to over the line.

The TV camera was caught between two frames and did not show definitely whether the ball crossed the line.

Fremantle's Matt Taberner controlled a mark on the goal line as the Dockers were mounting a comeback in the last quarter but it was not paid.

The ball was knocked out of his hands and rushed through for a behind, with the AFL's umpiring department ruling the umpire made an error not awarding the mark.

"The goal umpire presumed a mark, Dean Margetts, the field umpire, didn't pay the mark," AFL great Jonathan Brown said on Fox Footy at the time.

"Oh no, that's a shocking decision. That could be costly, that's a clear goal. Wow.

"That is a horror … I know the umpires have had some time off as well but that's not a complicated decision."

Originally published as New vision shows why Higgins was paid controversial mark

Jack Higgins’ mark from all angles. Picture: Supplied
Jack Higgins’ mark from all angles. Picture: Supplied


IN COURT: 15 people to face Maclean court today

Premium Content IN COURT: 15 people to face Maclean court today

Find out who's appearing in Maclean criminal court today

New look, new sound Clarence Valley Australia Day

Premium Content New look, new sound Clarence Valley Australia Day

Councillor declines nomination over “inappropriate” date

Blooming jacarandas provide boost for Grafton businesses

Premium Content Blooming jacarandas provide boost for Grafton businesses

After COVID-19 forced the cancellation of the annual Jacaranda Festival, many...